Apple Crisp
When my mom offered to host Thanksgiving, I asked what desserts she’d like me to bring. Her answer? “Pumpkin pie and that apple dessert you made two years ago, the one I’ve asked you to make four times since then.” What she didn’t say, but she and I both heard was, “And which you never made even though I asked you to serve it for Nathan’s first birthday.” And I did felt a little guilty when I (virtually) heard that, especially since I had made the crisp for Helen just days before.
The good part was that I had made the crisp only days previous. So, I knew where the problems with the crisp were, and I could ‘fix’ them for Thanksgiving.
Paul and I love America’s Test Kitchen. When I first decided to try my hand at apple crisp years ago, we pulled that recipe and made it. Our immediate reaction was, “This is delicious, but the tasters in the test kitchen hate topping.” We quickly increased the amount of topping by 50% which improved the crisp by roughly 500%. This is the huge fix in this recipe.
The second fix? America’s Test Kitchen tells you that you need cold butter for the topping. I go a step further and say your butter better darned well be frozen. Do not muck around with butter from your refrigerator unless you keep a subarctic fridge like my mother. If you use cold, but not frozen, butter, you will end up with a giant unappetizing lump of dough for your topping, not the “damp sand” texture desired. If you end up with said giant unappetizing lump of dough, do not give up. Work on breaking it up as best possible and top your crisp with it. As Tim Gunn would tell you, “Make it work!”
The last thing worth mentioning isn’t really a fix at all, but a personal preference. I love McIntosh apples and I love to not eat a meal prior to making my baked sweets. This means that when my McIntosh apples hit the bowl of sugar and lemon zest and juice mentioned in step 5 below, I start to snack on them. I normally eat about half an apple to a whole apple before I can stop myself. Due to this, if you’re like me, I’d suggest adding an extra McIntosh apple, 1/2 tablespoon of lemon juice, and an 1 tablespoon of sugar, and using a full rind of zest for this recipe.
Ingredients for Filling:
3 medium Granny Smith apples
3 medium McIntosh apples
1/2 teaspoon lemon zest
1 1/2 tablespoons lemon juice
1/4 cup granulated sugar
Ingredients for Topping:
8 tbls unbleached all purpose flour
7 tbls unsalted butter, chopped into 1/2 inch bits
1 1/4 cup chopped pecans
3/8 cup packed light brown sugar
3/8 cup granulated sugar
3/8 tsp ground cinnamon
3/8 tsp nutmeg (use fresh nutmeg and microplane for best results)
3/8 tsp salt
1. For the topping, put the flour, sugar, spices, and salt in your food processor. Don’t worry if you have a small one. My wimpy food processor handles this recipe like a pro! Pulse the ingredients once or twice to mix. Add the frozen butter. Pulse, pulse, pulse (about ten times) for 4 seconds each. Your topping should look like sand or coarse cornmeal. It should not be a big giant lump. if you got the lump, your butter wasn’t frozen enough, but don’t despair. You can break it up and use it, but it’s more work and it doesn’t look as good. Add the nuts, and do 4 one second pulses.
2. Make sure to refrigerate the topping for about 15 minutes or for the time to it takes to deal with the apples.
3. Turn on your oven to 375 degrees and make sure your oven rack is in the lower middle of your oven.
4. Peel, quarter, and core your apples. Cut them into 1 inch cubes.
5. Toss the apples, lemon juice, zest, and sugar in bowl. I usually combine steps 4 and 5, tossing each apple into the mix as soon as I’m done with it. This allows me to take a nice long Bejeweled break in the middle when I get tired of peeling and coring apples. It also allows me to snack on some of my McIntosh apples!
6. Pour this mix into 8 by 8 baking pan. Make sure to scrape the apple/lemon juice mix into that pan. Distribute the cooled topping on your apples, and cook for 40 minutes.
7. Crank the oven to 400 degrees for another 5 minutes.
8. Let it cool slightly on a nice cooling rack and then serve (warm) with a nice cinnamon ice cream or whipped cream.

























